Cold, green Europe: what happens when ideology wins over physics
“An anti-fossil fuel, anti-drilling European Union keeps its people alive only thanks to a pro-fossil fuel, pro-human government on the other side of the Atlantic.”– Vijay Jayaraj, RealClearMarkets
Europe presents itself as the self-proclaimed cathedral of green transition
Bureaucrats in Brussels and politicians in Berlin have spent decades lecturing the world on the moral imperative to renounce hydrocarbons. They have constructed a narrative of the European Union as a shining city powered by wind and sun, shaping a net-zero utopia.
But when the first real winter cold swept across the continent this fall, that facade collapsed under the weight of physical reality.
Europe relies on fossil fuels for about 70% of its total energy consumption. This figure has remained stubbornly consistent over the years, despite billions of euros spent on solar and wind infrastructure. The much-touted growth in those technologies masks a fundamental truth about energy systems that European policymakers refuse to publicly acknowledge: electricity is only a fraction of total energy demand.
Transportation, heating, industrial processes and manufacturing still run overwhelmingly on oil, natural gas and coal. Drawing attention to additions in renewable power generation while ignoring the broader energy picture is like being proud of a new front door while the rest of the house is in ruins.
In late November, the vulnerability of a weather-dependent energy system went on display as temperatures fell and demand for space heating rose. This is a predictable feature of life in the Northern Hemisphere, but European energy policy seems perpetually surprised by it.
Just when families needed warmth the most, the wind refused to blow. This is the “Dunkelflaute” – the dark windlessness – that engineers have been warning about for years. Wind generation plummeted 20%.
Grid operators, needing a backup source to prevent blackouts, did not turn to batteries – which remain hopelessly inadequate for the job. Instead, they turned to a workhorse of today’s energy systems: natural gas. Gas-fired generation increased by more than 40 percent to fill the gap left by stalled wind turbines.
In the Netherlands, heating degree days were 35% above the five-year average. Data from mid-November paints a devastating picture of the failure of so-called renewable energy. Between Nov. 14 and 21, when the first cold snap gripped the region, European gas demand shot up 45%.
In absolute terms, daily gas demand jumped by 0.6 billion cubic meters per day. This was not a gradual increase. It was the panic-led spike of a 75% increase in heating demand by households and businesses.
Gas storage sites were the unsung heroes of this drama, supplying about 90% of the jump in daily demand during a critical week. Withdrawals from storage facilities rose nearly 450%.
The magnitude of this intervention by natural gas is hard to overestimate. To put that 0.6 billion cubic meters of gas in perspective, the energy equivalent of that amount of gas is the daily output of 220 nuclear power plants – a number almost five times the size of the entire French nuclear fleet.
Imagine the catastrophe if Europe had achieved its net-zero goals and eliminated its gas infrastructure. There is no battery system on Earth, existing or planned, that can deploy the equivalent of 220 nuclear reactors.
Despite this ferocious gas consumption, prices have remained relatively stable. This was not due to European foresight. It was due to the “peace dividend” of possibly resolving the Ukraine conflict and, more importantly, a flood of liquefied natural gas from the United States.
Here lies the ultimate irony of the story: An anti-fossil fuel, anti-bore European Union is only keeping its people alive thanks to a pro-fossil fuel, pro-human government on the other side of the Atlantic.
The United States, by encouraging hydrocarbon production, created the surplus that now heats European homes.
Fossil fuels are the lifeblood of everyday life, especially in advanced societies that cannot run on the wishful thinking of wind and sun worshippers. The stability of European society today rests on the shoulders of American gas drillers.
The European Union serves as a warning of what happens when ideology defeats physics. Climate mandates cannot make the wind blow. The “green” emperor has no clothes on, and honey, it’s cold outside.